trade help

[ghosty]

12 team h2h points league i was offered trade .. JUSTIN UPTON, DENARD SPAN AND AARON HARANG FOR COLE HAMELS AND CARLOS QUENTIN
Should i take it?
my roster
(5-9)

C Mike Napoli, LAA C, DH
1B James Loney, LAD 1B
2B Robinson Cano, NYY 2B
3B Evan Longoria, TB 3B
SS Ryan Theriot, ChC SS
OF Grady Sizemore, Cle OF, DH
OF Scott Hairston, Oak OF
OF Scott Podsednik, CWS OF
UTIL Shane Victorino, Phi OF
UTIL Martin Prado, Atl 1B, 2B, 3B
P Cole Hamels, Phi SP
P Brian Fuentes, LAA RP
P Jonathan Broxton, LAD RP DTD
P Mark Buehrle, CWS SP
P Mike Pelfrey, NYM SP
P Jason Marquis, Col SP
P Ricky Nolasco, Fla SP
P Clay Buchholz, Bos SP
Bench Vladimir Guerrero*, LAA OF, DH DL15
Bench Scott Kazmir, TB SP
Bench Joba Chamberlain, NYY SP, RP
Bench Kyle Lohse, StL SP
Bench Mike Lowell*, Bos 3B DL15
Bench Nick Blackburn, Min SP, RP
Bench Tommy Hanson, Atl SP
Bench Jose Contreras, CWS SP
DL Carlos Quentin*, CWS OF DL15

[redsoxguru15]

You're going to take a hit on pitching, but Harang get's his fair share of K's...Upton and Span are an upgrade to Hairston and Podsednik...I'd take the deal!

From SportsExchange: According to manager Ozzie Guillen, the reports were still good, except Quentin was still tentative rounding the bases but OK running straight at them.

It looks like Quentin is going to need some time to get over the mental hurdle, he may not be right this season, I'd take the offer, you'll see an instant offensive improvement...

[ghosty]

ya iam leanin towards i

[hankhenshaw]

I would take the deal. Quentin's injury history was spotty before last year's breakout and now we're seeing more of the same. Meanwhile Hamels has not been consistently effective, yet clearly you have owners in your league willing to pay you via trade on what Hamels SHOULD be versus what he IS this year.

[ghosty]

if i can get the guy to add doumit in on the deal is it a plus?should i se doumit over napoli?

[kidsilk]

I would do it and definitely a plus if he adds Doumit. I like him over Napoli.

please help

viewtopic.php?t=393498

[ghosty]

ok i was asked to throw martin prado into the deal to get doumit.. should i add prado to get doumit or just leave the deadl as is?
so it would be upton/span/harang/doumit for hamels/quentin/prado

[ghosty]

.

[redsoxguru15]

I'd still do it, Prado isn't going to do much other than help your BA...if Doumit can stay healthy for the rest of the season....it will be a nice steal for you.