Trade McLouth?(keeper question) WHIR

[Big_Ben83]

I am in a 10 team keeper (keep 15). Roto scoring with normal 5x5 scoring. I was offered Hunter Pence, Leo Nunez and Alcides Escobar (minor league roster) for McLouth. I would have to decide on a contract if I kept McLouth as he is in his B year (currently 7, 4 dollars added each year) and Pence is under contract for 2 years after this with salaries of 9 and 13 respectively. Nunez wouldn't be kept due to his $8 dollar salary. What do you think? Roster below, planned keepers in bold, would probably drop Gaudin.

C
Matt Wieters
1B
Carlos Pena
2B
Orlando Hudson
3B
Evan Longoria
SS
Elvis Andrus
2B/SS
J.J. Hardy
1B/3B
James Loney
OF
Nate McLouth
OF
Chase Headley
OF
Ben Zobrist
OF
Jason Bay
OF
Jay Bruce
UTIL
Casey Blake
P
Max Scherzer
P
J.P. Howell
P
Joakim Soria
P
Huston Street
P
Chris Carpenter
P
Alfredo Aceves
P
Ricky Romero
P
Edwin Jackson
P
Chad Gaudin
Bench
Kendry Morales
Bench
Nolan Reimold
Bench
Gavin Floyd
Bench
Matt Holliday
DL
Carlos Guillen

[timozbuck]

I would do that deal if I were you. I think McClouth peaked last year and if you look at his stats since all-star break of 08, they aren't that good.

[Big_Ben83]

anyone else?

[blood5150]

I would do that deal if I were you. I think McClouth peaked last year and if you look at his stats since all-star break of 08, they aren't that good.

I would do it too.. you have some pretty good outfielders bolded that you are planning on keeping...