Mixed league, 10 teams, 6x6 H2H league with hits and Quality starts included so pitching is pretty important. Daily changes. I feel like I need some extra pitching and can afford to lose some of my OF depth.
I have been offered Roy Halladay and my choice of Papelbon or KRod for my Carlos Lee and Matt Holliday. Should I do it and if so should I ask for KRod or Papelbon?
First off, thank you for leaving an answer on my post. I would actually do this trade and ask for Papelbon (even though KRod wouldn't be too shabby, but I think Pap is the safer bet). Holliday is on your bench and you can plug in Choo for Lee. To get an ace like Halladay and a top 5 closer for Lee and a bench player, you got to pull the trigger.
This is an interesting deal. I love the potential addition of Halladay to your already nasty squad. I also like adding a top 5 closer to a weak bullpen. What I don't like is losing Holliday pending he gets dealt to a contender and begins to return to form. With that said, you can't bet on it, so I'd do the deal. Ask for Paps and secure yourself a playoff run.
Initially, I was thinking you shouldn't do this, but after looking at your OF depth, I think this could really help you. You enhance your SP staff and the addition of KRod OR Paps would be a huge improvement. I'd prefer Paps, btw though.