Ibanez+Rivera+Smoltz for Gallardo+Nolasco? WHIR

[clarkw267]

Was offered Gallardo+Lowe for Ibanez+Rivera. I countered with Gallardo+Nolasco for Ibanez+Rivera+Smoltz.

Good deal for me?

12 team 5x5 Roto, Keeper(Keep 6)
My Team
C - Napoli
1B - Pujols
2B - Lopez
3B - Youkilis
SS - Bartlett
OF - Braun
OF - BJ Upton
OF - Sizemore
UT - D Lee
BN - Rivera
BN - Ethier
DL - Ibanez

SP - J Santana
SP - W Rodriguez
RP - Rivera
RP - Rodney
P - Frasor
P - Myer
P - Wuertz
BN - Porcello
BN - Hanson
BN - Smoltz

[jlm53089]

Ibanez for Gallardo.

[dagactor]

I'd say Derrik Lee for Gallardo or Nolasco.

[lbblue]

I'd offer Rivera for Gallardo and expect to get rejected. Then I'd offer Rivera for Nolasco.

[clarkw267]

Bump... new offer.

[Tireur]

I like it, you are solid in the outfield and DH, this clears up a lot of roster space for you to grab either a streaming pitcher or another relief pitcher off the WW...


Wait wait wait, which Rivera? Do you mean Mariano or Juan Rivera? If it's Juan, I like the deal, if it's Mariano... I still kind of like it but less so of course, because Mariano is better and I think you could use some more trimming of your bats.

I like both Gallardo and Nolasco though for sure.

Help with mine? viewtopic.php?t=392901

[clarkw267]

It's Juan... and I'd have to drop someone to activate Ibanez anyways, so Smoltz is just a toss in.

[Tireur]

I unfortunately think Smoltz may be a fizzle this year and I don't mind him being a toss in. Gallardo and Nolasco will help your team a ton, and you still have a decent spot start bat in ethier, especially if he picks it up with Manny back in the lineup to take some of the pressure off of him.

I don't think you lose a ton of batting power for the makeup of your team and you improve your rotation a bunch. Good trade in my opinion.

[Emerald8h]

I like your proposal. You need pitching and your giving up a guy who you were doing without while sitting on the DL, a bench player, and Smoltz for two starters I think you need.

[clarkw267]

Bump... leave a link.