Wieters for G. Beckham and Wandy?

[LloydChristmas]

I get Wieters
I give Gordon Beckham and Wandy Rodriguez

12 yeam, H2H, redraft

We start 1 Catcher. I have Chris Iannetta. We start 2B, SS, 3B, no MI or CI. I have Utley, Barlett, Reynolds, Branyan, Aramis.

I have a deep starting pitcher staff too. Halladay, Lester, Ubaldo, Joe Saunders, Chris Volstad, Doug Davis.

Thoughts?

As always, will help in return right away.

[LloydChristmas]

I should immediately add that I kind of shit the bed and offered Wandy instead of Saunders but the offer on the table actually is:

I get Wieters
I give Beckham and SAUNDERS

Compare the two I suppose?

Are they both favorable deals for me? Just one? Neither?

[kevinss2001]

i would do either one--not to bad

I am not big on Wieters, but i do not like ianetta--if you want a personal opinion from my team--I went without a catcher for the first month--I am in 1st place right now--I do not know if you HAVE to start a catcher, but you can always go without them--they really do not do much unless you have a stud--and if you have a stud that you drafted high--your an idiot in my opinion. your not an idiot you have ianetta--I picked up aj pierz--off waivers about 2 weeks ago. also another option maybe.

[HOOTIE]

I wouldn't trade Wandy. I like Iannetta, but i would move Saunders.