It is clear by his second offer that his main goal is probably to obtain Longoria, and I cant say that I blame him. With that said, dealing longoria would be the only reason i would say this trade wouldnt leave a good taste in your mouth in the seasons to come (since its a keeper of course). but then again, pujols is undeniably a good producer in fantasy stats and also, since your league stats include SLG it makes him even better given his .739 SLG vs Longoria's .545. you have a tough choice ahead of you, i cant say what i would do without giving it more thought but i hope i gave you more food for thought.
I think you have to do it. Longoria is a young stud but currently Pujols is far and away the best player in baseball and will remain among the best for several years to come.
I'm a Royals fan and Gordon is trash, he'll never amount to anything worthwhile fantasy wise. Hill has shown he has the pedigree to be a stud, and pujols, well, pujols is pujols. Do this trade.
C Montero 1B Glaus 2B F. Lopez 3B A-Rod SS Reyes OF Hamilton OF Holliday OF Quentin Util Bruce BN G. Jones BN Aybar BN Morgan BN Ibanez
SP Felix, Johnson, Lincecum, Johan, Sanchez, Wandy, Nolasco, Volquez, Beckett RP Soria, K-Rod