Arod trade...what do you think? WHIR

[mj85]

I'm in first in a 12 team 5x5 roto league and was offered a deal for my Arod. I already have Wright, so losing a top 3b isn't a big deal. My problem is that I need SB and SV. He offered Zorbrist and Morales, which I promptly declined. I'm thinking of offering...

My: Arod, Cain, Podsednik for
his: Ellsbury, B Wilson, Billingsley

does this sound like a fair offer? others that he has of interst include: Manny, Reyes, Grienke and Victorino

My team is listed below.

c - B Molina
1b - Loney
2b - Ramirez
3b - Arod
ss - Tulowitzki
of - Abreu
of - Rios
of - Dye
ut - Wright
bn - Davis (AAA)
bn - Peralta
bn - Podsednik

sp - Lincecum
sp - Cain
rp - MacDougal
rp - Bailey
p - Gallardo
p - Nolasco
p - Liriano
bn - Morrow
bn - Schertzer
dl - Bedard

[justink15]

single season i would keep what you have, keeper i would do the trade.