do I dare sit Halladay?

[littletank]

I have 4 decent 2 starters going

h2h points,
6 win, -2loss, 1inning, 1k, -1 every 2er, -1 every 3 hits, -1 every 3 walks, 5 complete game, 5 shutout

I have Josh Johnson, Gallardo, Kershaw and Smoltz who all have decent 2 start matchups
Halladay goes @TB

Should I play Halladay over Smoltz?

[metsfan12]

I have 4 decent 2 starters going

h2h points,
6 win, -2loss, 1inning, 1k, -1 every 2er, -1 every 3 hits, -1 every 3 walks, 5 complete game, 5 shutout

I have Josh Johnson, Gallardo, Kershaw and Smoltz who all have decent 2 start matchups
Halladay goes @TB

Should I play Halladay over Smoltz?

With that point system I would probably agree with you and take 2 starts from Smoltz over 1 from Halladay. That system is a little too easy on ER. An inning where a guy gives up 3 hits and 2 ER is only -1 total points?