branyan and zobrist for jroll and votto?? WHIR

[trevizzle]

10 teams 5x5 H2H

C Brandon Inge
1B Carlos Pena
2B Ian Kinsler
3B Aramis Ramirez
SS Ben Zobrist
LF Shin-Soo Choo
CF Grady Sizemore
RF Hunter Pence
Utl Russell Branyan
Bn Michael Bourn
Bn Matt Holliday
DL Carlos Quentin

Sp Roy Halladay
Sp John Smoltz
Rp Ryan Franklin
Rp Huston Street
P David Aadrsma
P Derek Lowe
P Josh Johnson
Bn Carlos Zambrano
Bn Jon Lester
Bn Mark Buerhle

so with quentin and aram coming back soon, i need to make some moves to open up some roster spots. zobrist has obviously been hitting well, but the type of production he gives me is plenty on my team. i don't have many sb's, and i would love to get it from the SS position.

i've just been offered my branyan and zobrist for his jroll and votto. i think votto has been doing pretty well considering his injury. my fear is how well branyan has been hitting, but i think he's interchangable with branyan. and i get the upgrade i want at SS, especially since jroll is coming back around.

yes or no?

leave a link

[kidsilk]

I would do this deal in a heartbeat. You are selling high on two overachievers and buying low on one underachiever and one guy coming off injury. JRoll and Votto are stars and will have great second halves. I would definitely do this deal.

please help

viewtopic.php?t=392572

[jmcampbe11]

Absolutely do this deal.

[Dalingh]

no brainer IMO. rollins has been played well this weekend, maybe he's breaking out of his slump.

[Emerald8h]

Oooooo wow. Why don't people in my league offer trades like this?? DO IT....jroll is looking pretty good again and Votto's a stud. Honestly I think Branyan and Zobrist are here to stay but if you can get a chance to sell high for that kind of return, you have to take it.