Haren/Abreu/Morales - JSantana/Cruz/Loney ? ..WHIR

[SpecialFNK]

yahoo, 5x5, roto, 27 roster spots (21 starting/6 bench)

i give- Dan Haren, Bobby Abreu, Kendry Morales
i get- Johan Santana, Nelson Cruz, James Loney

EDIT- I ACCEPTED. no more replies needed

this was proposed to me. thoughts?

it seems fair, yet im hesitant.
the number one thing i want is to give Dan Haren and get Johan Santana.
IMO Morales right now is more valuable than Loney, but ive been only been using Morales at CI and i also gave Edwin Ecarnacion/Brandon Inge(3B)/Billy Butler to play along with Loney at CI, so losing Morales isnt a big deal. maybe with Manny back in the lineup that will benefit Loney?
Bobby Abreu has been coming on strong the last month(16/4/23/2/.292) compared to Cruz who has struggled(14/4/7/4/.193) ..but Cruz has been better on the season(45/19/47/13/.264) compared to Abreu(39/6/48/17/.295).

should i take this and be happy?
im not concerned with help in any one category.
HIM- R(12) HR(11) RBI(9) SB(12) AVG(10) W(10) SV(12) K(7) ERA(11) WHIP(11) =105 (1st)
ME- R(10) HR(10) RBI(7) SB(10) AVG(8.5) W(5) SV(8) K(8) ERA(12) WHIP(12) =90.5 (3rd)

MY ROSTER
CA- B McCann
1B- L Berkman
2B- C Utley
3B- B Inge
SS- D Jeter
CI- K Morales
MI- Y Escobar
OF- C Crawford
OF- B Abreu
OF- P Burrell
OF- N Reimold
UT- J Thome
UT- C Ross
BN- B Butler
BN- E Encarnacion
BN- C Coghlan
DL- A Gordon

SP- D Haren
SP- J Shields
RP- J Nathan
RP- T Hoffman
P- D Braden
P- J Vazquez
P- D Meyer
P- W Rodriguez
BN- R Johnson
BN- H Kuroda
BN- N Blackburn
DL- C Young


HIS TEAM
CA- R Hernandez
1B- J Loney
2B- R Cano
3B- D Wright
SS- E Renteria
CI- R Zimmerman
MI- A Hill
OF- C Granderson
OF- N Cruz
OF- R Ludwick
OF- A McCutchen
UT- J Ellsbury
UT- N Johnson
BN- J Hairston
BN- Ad LaRoche
BN- J Fox
BN- A Pierzynski
BN- Nate Schierholtz
DL- R Ibanez


SP- J Santana
SP- R Halladay
RP- B Jenks
RP- F Cordero
P- R Franklin
P- M MacDougal
P- F Hernandez
P- C Carpenter
BN- J Lannan
DL- S Marcum


leave a link, WHIR

[wkpdpack]

I'd do that trade. I prefer Santana over Haren and Cruz over Abreu. Loney and Morales in my mind are both just throw ins. So, I think you definitely get the better end of this deal.

Please help with my post viewtopic.php?t=392589