Which trade should I do?(WHIR)

[kidsilk]

Yeah, I don't think I will be catching the first two spots as I am about 20 points away. But, I can catch 3rd place and definitely get fourth place. Would trading for Cruz be that much of a downgrade from MCab that I would not be able to catch 3rd place? Danks has looked good and I think he is pretty on par with Shields at this point so I am not worried about that part of the trade.

[jweb2244]

I think Shields is going to have a good second half, and although I am not sure Cabrera is going to have as good a second half as last year, he is heating up also. I may be in the minority here, but I still am not sold on Cruz, although I do like Danks. The other deal I would not do at all. Bottom Line: although I am not familiar with keeper leagues other than in theory, I I think I would stay put.

Also, thanks for help on mine.

[mozart24]

I think you'll be fine with Cruz instead of MCab. It's a great long-term move, and I don't think the falloff will be that great. Maybe 20-30 points of battings average, but also an extra 10 steals. The other stats should be close.

Help with mine? viewtopic.php?t=392679

[Dalingh]

do the cruz/danks deal. danks has been coming into his own lately and cruz's production will most likely increase once Hamilton returns.

thanks for the help on mine.

[trevizzle]

if you have to trade mcab, then go for it. but personally you have the better sets of players.

[BUCCOFAN]

I like the CRUZ deal also. BUT I would think that you should be able to get more for M-CAB and SHIELDS dont you think??? M-CAB is arguably the best 1B in the AL??? Might be better off splitting Cabrera and Shields in separate deals, to maximize your return......Just a thought???

[kidsilk]

Opinions are kinda split on this one. Any more help would be appreciated from the Monday night crowd and Tuesday morning crowd. Thanks.