Was Offered A Huge Trade! Would Love some input...

[X-Factor611]

i was offered this trade in my 11 team league...
i give
Nelson Cruz
Cole Hamels
Tommy Hanson
David Price
Matt Garza
Troy Tulo
Nick Markakis

i get
Curtis Granderson
Jimmy Rollins
Justin Verlander
Francisco Liriano
Pat Burrell
Travis Hafner
Michael Cuddyer



the scoring is 5X4 (AVG HR RBI R SB / W SV ERA K)

the rest of my team is in my sig.

any thought?

[slink]

You lose big time imo.

Cruz = Granderson
Hamels > Verlander
Tulo = Rollins
Garza > Liriano

and then you're still throwing in markakis!!!

Burrell, Hafner and Cuddyer are all garbage.

Help? viewtopic.php?f=26&t=392550

[Knights]

I agree, you're giving up way too much and getting very little back that's better than what you're giving up. Don't make this deal.

viewtopic.php?t=392491

[SOUTHSIDE HITMEN]

You lose big time imo.

Cruz = Granderson
Hamels > Verlander
Tulo = Rollins
Garza > Liriano

and then you're still throwing in markakis!!!

Burrell, Hafner and Cuddyer are all garbage.

Help? viewtopic.php?f=26&t=392550

Like he said. I would say Verlander is better than Hamels but you still can't make that deal.

[yearbend]

You lose big time imo.

Cruz = Granderson
Hamels > Verlander
Tulo = Rollins
Garza > Liriano

and then you're still throwing in markakis!!!

Burrell, Hafner and Cuddyer are all garbage.

Help? viewtopic.php?f=26&t=392550

i disagree with every assessment there.

cruz < granderson
hamels < verlander
tulo < rollins
garza < liriano

he is right about those other 3 guys being trash though. if you can just get him to add a pitcher instead of those 3 i would go for it.