N. Cruz for Tulowitzki WHIR

[slink]

The situation: I am dead last in average and OPS and doing mediocre in all other hitting categories. I think I have a very strong outfield but I also have 2 good SS options, although neither are producing this year. I've been offered Tulowitzki for Nelson Cruz.

My team:
One year, 11 Team Roto League - 31 moves remaining

R,HR,RBI,SB,AVG,OPS
C: Napoli
1B: Pena
2B: Pedroia
3B: Reynolds
SS: Drew
OF: B. Upton, J. Upton, N. Cruz
Util: Victorino, Bay
Bench: McGehee, Rollins, J. Lopez, Adam LaRoche
DL: Beltre

W,L,K,SV,ERA,WHIP
SP: Lincecum, Oswalt, Gallardo, Harang, Gaudin
RP: Soria, F. Cordero, Rodney, Nunez

My question: Is Tulowitzki an upgrade on Rollins or Drew? Am I getting the better player in this deal? Would I be wise to take this deal and then use Tulo as my starting SS for the remainder of the season and try to move one of Drew/Rollins?

[FantasySportsMaven]

No way would I do this deal... unless you can get a deal for Rollins or Drew for a HR/RBI producer first. Cruz might be inconsistent and a 260 hitter, but when he is hot he puts em out frequently, and you need some power in your OF.

Help me too? viewtopic.php?t=392543

[yearbend]

rollins has a big game last night, give it two more weeks on rollins.

good luck.

[Tireur]

I don't believe that rollins will rebound this year. I think drew may rebound. I think tulo is just beginning his rebound and will be solid in the second half. I think it might be hard to move rollins and drew to be honest unless you can convince someone they are buy low. You will be losing quite a bit with cruz and I think his numbers will be similar or better when hamilton is back.I may look for a deal where you can deal both a SS and an OF for a shortstop, maybe you can keep your starting outfielders and upgrade your SS. Thanks for the help on mine.

[sigriffey]

Can you package Drew and McGehee or Drew and LaRoche for a better SS? Unless find a Rollins fanboy, it is a tougher sell.
N Cruz for Tulowitzki isn't bad, but it still leaves you with an OF vacancy of sorts and ROllins on the B.

[Knights]

I'd say no to this deal. You need Cruz in your OF, and I'm not in favour of carrying 3 SS, all of whom are stuggling, because you can't trade them and you'll just get more frustrated trying to figure out which of the 3 to start and which 2 to sit on the bench.