Need Help ASAP!!! HAMELS for WERTH

[X-Factor611]

im looking to make a deal...i was offered His Werth for my Cole Hamels...

should i accept this deal? i have N. Cruz and Adam Jones in my starting OF and im getting frustrated with their play as of late.

Will my pitching staff suffer? he hasnt been what i thought he would be this year.

my team is in my sig...
CBS Roto league 5x4 scoring (AVG HR RBI R SB/W SV ERA K)

any input is appreciated...

[ltrocq]

Will my pitching staff suffer?

that can't really be answered without you listing your pitching staff.

[X-Factor611]

SP-C.HAMELS
SP-C. CARPENTER
SP-M.GARZA
RP-B.FUENTS
RP-H. STREET
BN-HANSON,ZIMMERMAN,JURRJENS,PRICE,MILWOOD, PORCELLO

[pokerplaya]

Assuming 12 teams in you league, I think your staff would be too weak if you dealt Hamels. Even with his struggles, I'd hold him and hope for the best.

[ltrocq]

any bench OF or OF playing util?

[X-Factor611]

Francoer is my only OF on my bench...im picking up Rivera and Ross though for depth

[ltrocq]

why are you holding onto francoeur? i wouldn't do that trade. the guys you can pick up on WW are just as effective as werth.

[smoovethug]

I'm probably the biggest Hamels fan on board but yeah he has been struggling. Even so I would advise against selling him this low, not that Werth isn't good, but I think when Hamels inevitably turns it around you'll get a better return if you're still looking to sell.

[master453]

i'd pass. werth isnt much of an upgrade to cruz or jones. and hamels, though struggling now, has elite ace upside. this is the kind of deal where the upside gain for you is minimal, potential loss is huge.


viewtopic.php?t=392489

[Midnight_Toker]

im looking to make a deal...i was offered His Werth for my Cole Hamels...

should i accept this deal?

Would not hit.

Do not want.

Keep Rivera and drop Francoeur