Arod/jeter for Hanley

[master453]

5x5 dynasty league 16 team h2h.

offer is: his hanley for my arod and jeter

arod is my util (have longoria at 3b), and i would likely use a combo of either butler/rowand/hideki matsui at util to replace him(currently my bench)

currently in 3rd place, short term, i think its a small downgrade...but long term a win...

should i pull the trigger?
whir

[graalmeister]

How many keepers? Short term I don't like it at all. It also seems like you're overpaying for long-term gains, but again, that depends on how many keepers you get.

[master453]

its dynasty....(keep everyone)

[Tom Emanski AllStars]

in a dynasty...this is an easy yes. Like you mention yourself, this year it might be a slight downgrade, but for the future this is huge.

[jweb2244]

I'm not sure it's even that much of a downgrade this year, and I like the idea of rotating in the hot hitter at Utility. I would definitely do it.

And thanks for help on mine.

[Midnight_Toker]

well, since it is a keeper ... I think I'd go through with it. Hanley is a Great Keeper, especially with his age compared to A - Rods.

[jmcampbe11]

I'd do it. A-Rod's injury (and slow start) has to give some cause for concern. Hanley's younger and apporaching his prime. Including Jeter wouldn't be a dealbreaker either. He's having a nice season, which probably has more to do with the new ballpark then anything he's done, but he's been on the declien for several years.

[ltrocq]

try to sub longoria into the trade first and see if he'll do it. if he won't, i would do the arod deal.

[yearbend]

i like this trade for you. very rare talent hanley ramirez is. hopefully they do not change his position or you will be ripped off! but if he ticks at SS i love this trade for you.