Better keeper: Lester or Ethier?

[dannahann]

12 team 7 x 7 roto keeper. Extra cats are HR allowed, Losses and OPS, Hits.
It's difficult to project who my other keepers will be because most of my present keeper types will be vulnerable to takeover bids when their contracts expire this winter. Both Ethier and Lester will be free to sign without takeover risk. I need each about equally this season. I have the opportunity to move one for the other, who will make the better keeper into 2010, Lester or Ethier?

[twistedude]

Lester. for sure imo Higher upside

[slink]

Lester. As the poster above said, much higher upside and he`s starting to show some of that upside this year.

Help? viewtopic.php?t=392483

[ltrocq]

lester - if he wouldn't have started out terribly, he would be one the top fantasy producing pitchers.

[master453]

i'd keep lester over ethier.


viewtopic.php?t=392489

[dannahann]

Looking like a runaway for Lester thus far, I must've been overthinking this into a closer call than it is? Maybe putting too much stock in how Ethier fared when manny came to LA last summer? Thanks for the help so far.

[jmcampbe11]

One more vote for Lester. Even with all his success Ethier is still batting .250.

Any thoughts on this one? viewtopic.php?t=392509