A Rod for Braun WHIR!

[sreill]

Im in last place of a keeper league. I was offered braun for arod. Based on age alone, do i do it?

[DaShiz23]

post your roster, as well as your keeper rules. this appears to be an interesting decision.
I lean towards the ARod side, but more info would help.

[tribefan08]

in a keeper i say ya gotta do it....

[KSig24]

I too am in last place. Is A-Rod or Braun a keeper in your league?

[sreill]

Well I have thrown in the towel for this year, so roster isnt really important. Ive traded away alot of guys to get extra picks for next year. I currently have 3 first round picks and 2 second round picks

My current keepers are Reyes, Utley, Arod, Beltran, B. Roberts or Russ Martin as my fifth

No keeper rules. Keep your best 5

[KSig24]

I would take Braun all day. How long do
you get to keep him for?

[bigslickak]

Very even trade in a keeper. If you're going with the youth movement anyways, I say why not?

[sreill]

i can keep a player forever. no rules

[sreill]

Im taking into consideration positions scarcity also There will be no decent third baseman available next year due to the few good ones being kept.

[yearbend]

i will take the braun side. arod is OLD.