My Soriano/Rollins/Kershaw for Greinke/Votto/Jeter? WHIR

[sigriffey]

Do I do this deal?

I Give: Rollins, Soriano, Kershaw
I GET: Greinke, Votto, Jeter


12 Team H2H league, with 6 Keepers -- (Keepers go back into the draft after 2010).

stat categories: R, 1B, 2B, 3B, HR, RBI, SB, BB, AVG -- IP, W, L, CG, ER, ERA, K, SV, WHIP


My Team:

C Wieters
1B Pujols (K)
2B Pedroia (K)
SS Rollins (K)
3B E.Longoria
OF Soriano (K)
OF Granderson
OF Podsednik
UT Miggy Cabrera (K)
UT Napoli
UT F.Sanchez
B Griffey, Beckham, Mcgehee



SP Sabathia (K), Billingsley, Lilly, Slowey, Kershaw, Hanson, A.Cook
RP Broxton, Street, Nunez
DL: Peavy (K)

[Tom Emanski AllStars]

i think i'd stay away from deal #1...rollins (even as bad as he's been) and pedoria offers more to your team than Felix and MYoung.

As for deal #2...i like it. Soriano, yes he'll rebound and put up some decent number (my opinion), but getting Votto and Grienke for Soriano and a pitcher is a hell of a deal.
i'd offer Kershaw...and here's why:
1) he's not going to be one of your keepers
2) he struggles with the BB and an ability to get deep into games (IP)
3) Lilly brings the same level of performance with little longer track record.
4) Kershaw upside is higher but he's not going to be one of your keepers and i think for the remainder of this year; he and lilly will be similar.


thanks for the help with mine

[Tom Emanski AllStars]

i don't know if i like the new deal....as much as rollins has struggled and continues to struggle, I still see him as a top 5 SS in the future and in a keeper league that's what I look at. If you are absolutely fed up with Rollins than i'd do the deal. But if you can stomach his current slump and get out of your mind his former 30/30 self, I'd try to keep him out of this deal.

[sigriffey]

Do you like the deal as Soriano and Kershaw for Votto and Greinke?

Who do u see having the better second half: Rollins or Soriano? neither i am sure i want to keep next year after their campaigns to-date...

[baseketball4life]

no way would i do this trade... from your side... Soriano and Rollins will have great 2nd halves also Kershaw is very consistent, only 1 bad turn really all year, 3 IP 9 ER at colorado early, take that out and his ERA/WHIP look brilliant with the Ks...

[sigriffey]

Do one of these?

1.) Soriano and Kershaw for Votto and Greinke
2.) Rollins and Kershaw for Jeter and Greinke
3.) Rollins, Soriano and Kershaw for Jeter, Votto and Greinke