Trade Ted Lilly and Konerko for Vlad Guerrero?

[Howie]

Should I do this deal? If I don't, who should I drop when Aramis Ramirez returns on Monday? Thanks.

10 team h2h, 6x6 (standard cats plus ops and hr allowed)

c - v. martinez
1b - helton
2b - cano
3b - m. cabrera
ss - jeter
of - hart
of - holliday
of - abreu
util - davis
util - konerko
dl - beltran
dl - a. ramirez

sp - halladay
sp - lackey
sp - kershaw
rp - lidge
rp - fuentes
rp - m. gonzalez
p - street
p - jimenez
bench - nolasco
bench - lilly
bench - harang
bench - kazmir
bench - hanson

[Nails86]

Dont make this deal. Do not trade for a name. Vlad is no longer Vlad. It is a good idea to try to trade 2 guys for one before Aramis comes back but this is not the right deal. Vlad has 6 extra base hits in the past month. On the other hand, you dont have any droppable guys so try to make a 2 for 1 deal this weekend!

[travisjz]

Don't make the trade. I wouldn't trade either of those guys straight up for Vlad, let alone both. If you have to drop someone, I'd drop Davis.

[amarlls]

Ya I think you stay put. Vlad is not holding up to his projections and his rep.

Please help viewtopic.php?t=392219

[got2bdab]

Although I think Vlad is going to improve, Paulie is heating up and Lilly is pretty consistent. I would not do the deal.

Help with mine?
viewtopic.php?t=392225