Cruz/Holliday/Carp for Utley/Zobrist? WHIR 100%!

[master_herm]

So I'm thinking of sending Cruz, Holliday, and Carp in exchange for Utley and Zobrist. I'm streaming pitchers so Carp isn't a big loss; I never win ERA/WHIP anyway and I think he's gotta come back to earth or get hurt. Holliday I really like but I'm getting Utley, and Cruz's streakiness has been killing me in H2H. I don't know what to make of Zobrist but I think I can get him to throw him in.

Would you do this deal?

My team:

C: Weiters
1B: Howard
2B: As. Cabrera
3B: M-Cab
SS: Hanley
OF: Soriano
OF: Holliday
OF: Cruz
Util: Lind
Util: Ellsbury
Util: Ludwick

Pitching: pretty much streaming; Carp is no loss.

[master_herm]

bump?

[master_herm]

bump.

[D.Piston]

So I'm thinking of sending Cruz, Holliday, and Carp in exchange for Utley and Zobrist. I'm streaming pitchers so Carp isn't a big loss; I never win ERA/WHIP anyway and I think he's gotta come back to earth or get hurt. Holliday I really like but I'm getting Utley, and Cruz's streakiness has been killing me in H2H. I don't know what to make of Zobrist but I think I can get him to throw him in.

Would you do this deal?

My team:

C: Weiters
1B: Howard
2B: As. Cabrera
3B: M-Cab
SS: Hanley
OF: Soriano
OF: Holliday
OF: Cruz
Util: Lind
Util: Ellsbury
Util: Ludwick

Pitching: pretty much streaming; Carp is no loss.

I like that deal for you. I always value hitters more than pitchers. Plus, I think Carpenter and Holliday are both great , but also injury risks waiting to happen. I too, am trying to sell Carpenter. But, Utley will greatly improve your 2B position and Zobrist is a multi-positional threat that you can plug in at OF to replace Cruz or have when other injuries hit in other positions. Cruz has been a beast but Utley's power is more consistent and predictable. Take that trade.

Thanks for helping me.

[master_herm]

Ok what if it's just Utley? I could pick up Reimold or Nick Johnson off the FA to fill in. Still worth it?