Would you do this trade?? WHIR

[Emerald8h]

10 team yahoo h2h league 10x10 stats: There's one guy who is dangling Torii Hunter and Brandon Phillips. In return he wants a really solid SP. I am thinking offering him Greinke, Rios, and Scutaro for both of them. Right now Phillips is on his bench. With these stats, Rios is def. my weakest OF but he's still 92% owned. Would you offer this trade/is it reasonable?

R 1B 2B 3B HR RBI SB BB AVG OBP

IP W L SHO SV K HR ERA WHIP K/BB

C Empty
1B Tex
2B Scutaro
3B Branyan
SS Tulo
OF Crawford
OF Markakis
OF Rios
UTIL Abreu
UTIL Ortiz
BN Rollins
DL Beltran, Doumit, Quentin

SP Beckett, Greinke, Oswalt, Harden, Slowey, Baker, Harang
RP Wilson, Fransisco, Qualls

[dracovonborax]

you are fat at sp to be sure. not sure i'd start with Greinke but the move looks sound to me.
viewtopic.php?t=391843

[yearbend]

you have quentin + beltran on the DL, i would not look to trade for another OF. and phillips over scutaro sure, but not grainke for him. offer someone like oswalt for him.

[Emerald8h]

bump, few more opionions

[yanks0826]

you have quentin + beltran on the DL, i would not look to trade for another OF. and phillips over scutaro sure, but not grainke for him. offer someone like oswalt for him.

I agree with this guy right here.


Help me?

viewtopic.php?t=391851