Trade Nelson Cruz & Andrew Baliey for Jason Bay?

[devastor]

Hey all,

I am in a 10 team league. I trade Nelson Cruz & Andrew Bailey for Jason Bay. I know I am selling low of Cruz but I think its a definite upgrade. What do yall think?

Here is my team:
C: J. Posada
1st:J. Morneau
2nd: B. Roberts
3rd: K. Youkilis
SS: S. Drew
OF: R. Braun, A. Rios, J. Rivera
Util: J. Cantu (3B,2B), B. Abreu (OF)
BN: T. Helton (1B)
DL: R. Ibanez, C. Quentin

SP: J. Beckett, C. Sabathia, M. Buehrle
RP: J. Nathan, H. Bell
P: G. Sherrill (RP), R. Franklin (RP), A. Baliey (RP)
BN: N. Blackburn (SP)

[Howie]

No doubt. You have the closer depth to lose Bailey, and Cruz is too much "boom or bust" at the plate for my liking.

Help?

viewtopic.php?t=391738

[yearbend]

looks like a good trade, get bay!

[devastor]

thanks guys.

[ltrocq]

while everyone thinks cruz is for real, no one truly knows for sure. i would do this trade since bay is a proven commodity and the big papi protection will only help his numbers.