Ethier and Wieters for Youkilis?

[Howie]

I would be getting Youkilis as I really need a 3B. The guy I'm trading with really needs a C. Is this a fair offer or is it going to get rejected?

10 team roto 7x7

c - v. martinez
1b - pujols
2b - uggla
3b - stewart
ss - jeter
ci - votto
mi - tulowitzki
of - holliday
of - abreu
of - adam jones
of - bj upton
util - helton
bench - m. ramirez
bench - konerko
bench - ethier
bench - atkins
bench - wieters
bench - pierre

sp - halladay (dl)
sp - greinke
sp - shields
rp - broxton
rp - gonzalez
rp - capps
p - downs (dl)
p - frasor
p - nolasco
bench - scherzer
dl - volquez
dl - webb

[BigRy]

i think its a fair offer considering Ethier just had a huge game and Manny will be back soon which has really been a big boost for Ethier in the past. And Wieters have done a solid job so far. If it were offered to me id certainly consider. However does he have a 3b to replace Youklis with? That would be the catch.

help?

viewtopic.php?t=391757

[yearbend]

i would keep ethier and wieters.

[I Stumped the Schwab]

its a really good idea, but id trade someone like abreu instead of ethier, like others said, he could really heat up with manny back

[jmcampbe11]

I like the move...especially considering you already have V-Mart. Pull the trigger.
Help with mine plz -http://www.fantasybaseballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=391776

[graalmeister]

I don't see the other guy accepting this trade. But it's a big upgrade at 3B, so I'd give it a shot.

[bmfote]

i personally would not accept this trade. i am a fan of Ethier and Wieter, their both on my team but... youky is the shit. Either way, how i look at it is: i think you would benefit more from the two (Ethier and Wieters), way more than just youky.


Just my twocent.

<3 bmfote

[Deadfish]

I think its a very fair offer....and it definitely helps your team. You have an excess of very good outfielders and a lack of a decent thirdbaseman. The guy might not accept your offer, but it should start a dialogue... I would also look at any other team that has an excess at third...gook luck

[MasChingon]

Id try Abreu/Wieters first, build up Abreus steals.

Yeah with Manny coming back Fri, Ethier could blow up and start hitting again consistently.

Curious, who's on the waivers that you would pick up?