Give: Felix/J.Upton Get: CC/Holliday. Thoughts? WHIR

[Box]

Guy in my league is desperate to trade (for some reason) and I think I can take some value from him. He offered this today.

I Give:
Felix Hernandez
Justin Upton

I Get:
CC Sabathia
Matt Holliday

I'm honestly on the fence. Felix and Upton are both hot and helping me out big time. CC and Holliday are so so, but could end up having monster second halves.



My roster(10th place):

12 team Mixed 6 keepers .
Normal 5x5 plus (1B,2B,3B,SO,BB; HLD,CG,BB,IP)
C: McCann 1B: Fielder 2B: O. Hudson
3B: Stewart SS: Furcal
OF: Sizemore, J. Upton, Rowand
Util: Blalock
DL: Hamilton, Beltran

SP: J. Santana, Felix, Kershaw, Harang, Jiminez, Jurrjens, Floyd, Contreras
RP: Soriano, Hawkins, Street, Nunez, Aardsma


His roster(3rd place):
C: Barajas 1B: Texiera 2B: Phillips
3B: Wright SS: Jeter
OF: Ellsbury, McCutcheon, Pierre
Util: Ad. Laroche
Bench: Holliday, J. Rivera


SP: CC, W. Rodriguez, A. Miller, Scherzer, Volstad, J. Vazquez, Richmond, Mazzaro
RP: Fuentes, M. Gonzalez, Bailey
DL: Peavy, T. Hudson

[yearbend]

id take the CC/holliday side.

[dssguy99]

Id take CC and Holliday too...but if its a keeper league I may not!

[bigslickak]

Thanks for the help on mine.

I would do this. Holliday's value may go higher if he gets dealt at the deadline, as has been rumored.

[dubstar]

i like the CC/Holliday side. Although, I am starting to think Holliday is staying in Oakland. If you decide not to, I don't think you are missing out on much. You would be fine just stayng put as well.