Drop Dukes for Scott Hairston?

[sambafreak13]

Scott Hairston is coming off my DL and I need to drop someone for him...Elijah Dukes seems like the best choice...I know he has the upside, but I'm currently first in HR and LAST in Avg...Hairston hits consistently over .300 (and now is getting a chance to play every day)and Dukes isn't giving me a lot in any category so far. thoughts? drop someone else?

11 Team 5x5 Roto

C-McCann
1B-A Gonzales
2B-Alexei Ramirez
SS-Christian Guzman
3B-Felipe Lopez
OF-BJ Upton
OF-Luke Scott
OF-Posedinik
Util-Ludwick
Util-Thome
BN-Dukes
BN-Jay Bruce
BN-Chris Davis
DL-Hairston
DL-Jose Reyes

SP-A.J. Burnett
SP-Nolasco
RP-Sherrill
RP-Mike Gonzales
P-Harang
P-Kershaw
P-Gavin Floyd
P-J Frasor
P-JP Howell
DL-Roy Halladay

[Neboguy]

Drop Dukes or Chris Davis. I'd go with Dukes as OF is a less scarce position and Davis can play 1B or 3B.