Carpenter/Ellsbury for ARod

[mdgoalie]

What do you guys think?
I would be giving up Carpenter/Ellsbury for ARod.
Good, bad, even...?
Should I try to substitute Ellsbury with somebody else?
3rd base is easily the weakest part of my lineup with Cantu and Chris Davis so I have been looking to upgrade it for awhile.

8 Team H2H - HR, R, RBI, SB, TB, OBP x W, K, ERA, WHIP, Saves, QS

My Team - everyone listed that is not on the bench is in a starters spot
C: Sandoval
1B: Pujols
2B: Utley
SS: Drew
3B: Cantu
MI: Phillips
CI: Dunn
OF: Kemp, Holliday, Ellsbury, JUpton, Bruce, BJ Upton
Util: Abreu, Hill
SP: Lincecum, Floyd, Gallardo, Greinke, Carpenter, EJackson
RP: Broxton, Jenks, Hoffman

Bench: CDavis, LScott, Vazquez, FFrancisco
DL: Halladay

Thanks

[rpdfire07]

try carp just for Arod first. I got Carp for A Gonz

[BBandit]

Yeah, AROD's value is at its lowest. try and take advantage.

Why not offer Carpenter and Cantu for Arod.

Ellsbury should have more value than Cantu.

[mdgoalie]

Thanks for the responses
I think I already tried it with cantu.
What about Carp/Abreu, Carp/Hill?

[BBandit]

i would do that deal. Hill can't keep up this pace.

[Bobby B 11]

yeah give up hill, he has no track record of ever being THIS good. hills best season waas .291 17 HRs in 600 ABs

[mdgoalie]

yeah give up hill, he has no track record of ever being THIS good. hills best season waas .291 17 HRs in 600 ABs

alright I'll try that
And just one more possibility, what about carp/bruce?

[mbea02]

Do it. You're getting the best player in the deal.

viewtopic.php?t=391355

[Robin Hood]

I'd do any of those deals mentioned in order to acquire Arod.

[mdgoalie]

He countered with Carpenter/Abreu and I took that deal
Thanks for all the advice