A fair price for Utley..WHIR

[uk_bosox]

14 team mixed league ....Non Keeper! Stats are (R), (HR), (RBI), (SB), (TB), (AVG), (OBP), (XBH)

I give Chase Utley and receive Alexei Ramirez and Brian McCann....

My current C is R Hernandez

Any advice gratefully received.

[slcdcricket]

What other catchers are available on the WW? Even still i might not take the trade since Utley plays in the Phillies lineup and, well, he's Utley. McCann may get you some Avg and such but he plays for the braves and even with McClouth they are not a powerhouse offensively. Alexei may be good, but he's not close enough to Utley for me to think it's worth it.

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=391290&p=3115292#p3115292

[sigriffey]

Hmm it seems like a lot to give up -- this is a lot like my Cabrera for Lincecum/DLEE deal ... hard to give up the best player in the deal. If you are ok with that, it is decent return.

[fierro33]

i dont like it...utley is the top 2b and very valuable.......mccann doesnt even look all that great this year......


viewtopic.php?t=391313

[Mashug]

I like Ramirez and McCann, but it's just not enough in return for the best 2B in baseball.

[BBandit]

The idea is good, but Utley is just too valuable.

The difference between Utley and Alexei is greater than McCann and Ramon in my opinion, but its close.

[Bobby B 11]

i got Cano, Gallardo, and Max Scherzer for Utley. But my pitching was atrocious which is why i did it.

i like cano in that tiny yankee stadium =)

[BBandit]

if you needed the pitching, its a fair return. Gallardo is a stud.