Is this too much to get Utley... WHIR

[TheBambino]

My Zobrist and Matt Holliday
for
Utley

I have tons of OFs so i feel I can afford to lose Holliday... especially since I may not be keeping him for next year since we can only keep 6... If I land Utley I would be keeping for the next 2 years

Morneau
Utley
Grady
Bay
Haren
Nathan

Does this trade make sense for me?

Thanks and leave a link

___________________________________________
10 Team 3 Year Keeper (Keep 6) Mixed 5x5 Roto League

C: Pierzynski
1B: Morneau
2B: Roberts
SS: Jeter, Tulowitzki
3B: A. Ramirez
OF: Sizemore, Holliday, Bay, M Ramirez, Pence
UTIL: Zobrist, Reynolds
SP: Haren, Lackey, J Johnson, Carpenter, Scherzer
RP: Nathan, Downs, Lindstrom, Howell

[woowoo crew]

yeah, since, you can keep utley for 2 years, it makes sense for you. your OF is solid. while i'm high on zobrist, getting utley in a keeper league is awesome. your list of keepers looks strong.

help me please: viewtopic.php?t=390693

[murphysxm]

I don't think it's enough to get him. I wouldn't make this trade if I was the Utley owner


Help me if you can
viewtopic.php?t=390749

[TheBambino]

Its been offered to me... Take it? I hate giving up Holliday and Zobrist though! If Holliday gets traded and explodes and Zobrist keeps on fire..... I lose big time! haha

[murphysxm]

If it was offered, keep it on the table and counter. Try getting an outfielder to help replace Zobrist

[TheBambino]

I dont need anyone to replace him..... Im pretty stacked in what he has to offer me. Put it this way.. when healthy, id be benching either Matt Holliday, Hunter Pence or Manny Ramirez... I dont think i need another OF!

and at SS and 2b (I have Jeter, and Tulo as a spare and now Utley and Roberts as a spare)

If I accept am I sitting pretty?

[yearbend]

that is not too much, that seems like not enough to me. but then again i am an utley owner so it may be just me that thinks holliday is trash.

[TheBambino]

bump