How Bad?

[camperking]

I just accepted a trade that has me trading Holliday for Carpenter. I was thinking that my O is strong enough that I could let him go. Did I screw up? Having buyers remorse!


C Chris Iannetta
1B Chris Davis
2B Chone Figgins
3B Kevin Youkilis
SS Derek Jeter
OF Matt Holliday
OF Adam Lind
OF Matt Kemp
Util Todd Helton
BN Colby Rasmus
BN Willy Taveras
BN Freddy Sánchez
DL Edwin Encarnación

SP Daisuke Matsuzaka
SP Randy Wolf
RP Kerry Wood
RP Matt Capps
P Trevor Hoffman
BN Félix Hernández
BN J.A. Happ - -
BN Jake Peavy

[angels7777]

very risky deal for you - I personally would have waited for a healthier pitcher, but if he Carp stays healthy its a fine deal

[WyldStallyn]

well, carpenter has been pitching very well this year, but i dont think he has to stamina to last till the end of the year (didnt really pitch 2 prev seasons). you definitely overpaid, but you do need some SP help

[jake_twothousandfive]

It's extremely unlikely that Carpenter stays healthy for the rest of the year. If he does, you did fine. If he doesn't, then well...you gave up a great bat for a good looking name on your DL.