Help w/ 2 Trades(Hamilton, B.J., Dunn...) WHIR

[StLouisFan1972]

My first question was about whether to offer Aaron Hill for Josh Hamilton. The owner of Hamilton is pretty low on him and fairly high on Hill, and he is weak at 2nd base.

I have Smoltz coming off the DL soon, so I could stash Hamilton on the DL.

My Team:

C-Mauer
1B-Pujols
2B-Hill
SS-Drew
3B-Longoria
OF-Dunn
OF-Zobrist
OF-Bourn
Util-Ortiz
BN-McCutchen

SP-Gallardo, Burnett, J. Shields, Slowey, Zambrano, Hanson, Smoltz(DL)
RP-Rivera, Fuentes, Valverde, Lindstrom, Madson

My second question was about a Dunn/B.J. Upton trade. I don't know whether he would do 1-for-1, but what do you think I could/should give in addition to Dunn in order to get Upton.

His Team:

C-Russel Martin
1B-Teixera
2B-B. Phillips
SS-Rollins
3B-Blalock
OF-B.J. Upton
OF-Mike Cameron
OF-Beltran
Util-Ethier
BN-C. Davis
BN-Ludwick
BN-Matsui
BN-Kubel
DL-Nady

SP-Wainwright, Lilly, Cueto, Garza, 1 streaming spot
RP-Wood, Howell, Bailey

His closers are woeful but I don't think he is looking to upgrade there.

Any advice on either, or both of these would be greatly appreciated.

Post a link and I'll do my best to help on yours as well.

[Bobby B 11]

i wouldnt do it. i dont see hamilton getting out of this injury funk anytime soon this yr

[jweb2244]

I don't see much value in Hamilton and would not be in a rush to trade Hill, but if you really want to trade him, I would try to get something more in return...I'm just not much of a Hamilton fan, even before the injury.

Thanks for help on mine.

[mrd3licious]

keep hill for now

[rippz]

I don't see he him selling low on Hamilton for Hill with Phillips on his team anyway so I wouldnt even make that offer.

Dunn for Upton would be sweet.

[yanks24716]

keep hill

if you need to give up more than dunn throw in one of your rp

viewtopic.php?t=390736