smoltz/jp howell/madson WHIR

[fierro33]

i own madson/lidge and with lidge coming back soon im wondering if i should pick up smoltz(drop madson) and then stash smoltz on the DL in place of lidge, then pick up jp howell. What do u guys think? its a risk since there is a chance lidge might falter again, but getting 2 extra potentials smoltz and howell by just dropping one sort of temporary guy seems like a good plan yes? or is madson just that good and howell isnt.




10 team non keeper 5x5 h2h

C Joe Mauer
1b Miguel Cabrera
2b Brian Roberts
3b Alex Rodriguez
ss Jimmy Rollins
OF Carl Crawford
OF Nate Mclouth
OF Ichiro Suzuki
Util Adam Jones
Andre Ethier
Manny Ramirez
Aaron Hill

CC Sabathia
Yovani Gallardo
Josh Johnson
Adam Wainwright
Kevin Slowey
Scott Baker

Brian Fuentes
Matt Capps
Ryan Madson
Brad LIdge DL

[fierro33]

anyone?

[sigriffey]

A healthy Smoltz with that Red Sox offense and pen is worth angling for if you can. If Lidge is healthy, he will have the job, so I say take a gamble here.

[fierro33]

i guess i cant do simple math.....i dropped madson for smoltz...placed smoltz on DL and activated lidge, but now i have no room to pick up howell...i thought for some reason this move would create an open roster space.....plan backfired oh well

[fierro33]

so the question is now......would u drop baker for howell?

[dubstar]

no i would not drop baker.

thanks for the reply on mine...

[smoovethug]

Don't drop Baker for Howell. Baker is finally coming around and should have a fine 2nd half.