Just offered Hamels...need help deciding

[mbea02]

Just got an interesting trade offer:

I get: Hamels
I give: Napoli and Sherrill

Catchers on the Wire are pretty thin: Ianetta, Saltalamacchia, Y. Molina, Hernandez, Olivo, Shoppach
Closers on the Wire are also thin: MacDougal, Hanrahan, Hawkins, Choate, Wheeler, Ziegler, Howell

Should I do it? If so, who do I pick up to fill the spot at Catcher?


--------------------
12-team Roto League. 6x6 with OPS and QS

C: M. Napoli
1B: M. Teixeira
2B: D. Pedroia
SS: Hanley Ramirez
3B: A. Beltre
OF: C. Lee
OF: Adam Jones
OF: J. Werth
UT: L. Berkman
UT: J. Pierre

BN: Manny Ramirez
DL: Aramis Ramirez

SP: Lincecum, Lackey, Lester, Liriano, Nolasco
RP: Wood, Sherrill, Aardsma
DL: Kazmir, Peavy

[Some Guy 15]

As far as replacing your Catcher goes, I think Molina is the most consistant producer out of that group and he's in a great lineup. And his stats arent very far off from Napoli.

What bothers me about this trade is giving up Sherrill especially since this Roto and you will def suffer for it without a clear replacement.
But Hamels is a nice addition to your pitching staff. So based on this I would pull the trigger on this trade and hope you can pick up a closer via injury.

IMO