I was offered Brian Roberts, Corey Hart, and Joe Saunders for Halladay in a 12 team H2H league about a week ago. I hadn't gotten around to rejecting the trade yet and actually forgot about it until I was setting my line up for the next few days. I think Corey Hart stinks, and I'm not big on Saunders. I also need a shortstop and have no use for another 2nd baseman. So there was no need for me to even consider it. However, no that Halladay has a mystery injury and no info about the severity of this injury is being released, I'm wondering if I should take advantage of this offer.
C John Baker(Fla - C) 1B Lance Berkman(Hou - 1B) 2B Orlando Hudson(LAD - 2B) 3B Aubrey Huff(Bal - 1B,3B) SS Willie Bloomquist(KC - SS,OF) OF Álex Ríos(Tor - OF) OF Adam Dunn(Was - 1B,OF) OF Nelson Cruz(Tex - OF) Util Prince Fielder(Mil - 1B) Util Mark Reynolds(Ari - 1B,3B) BN Gordon Beckham(CWS - 3B,SS) DL Grady Sizemore(Cle - OF) DL SP Aaron Harang(Cin - SP) SP Roy Halladay(Tor - SP) SP Javier Vázquez(Atl - SP) RP Matt Capps(Pit - RP) RP Ryan Franklin(StL - RP) P Brandon Morrow(Sea - SP,RP) P Mike MacDougal(Was - RP) P Yovani Gallardo(Mil - SP) BN John Maine(NYM - SP) DL BN James Shields(TB - SP) BN Randy Wolf(LAD - SP) BN Tommy Hanson(Atl - SP) BN Chris Volstad(Fla - SP) BN Clayton Kershaw(LAD - SP) DL Brad Lidge(Phi - RP) DL
tough call - obviously Halladay is a stud when healthy and Saunders and Hart are not guys I am particularly high on - Roberts is probably close in value to Halladay - can you wait a few more days to get an injury update? I mean if the other guy realizes Halladay's injury it is his job to take down the offer
Moderately active. I don't think he checks every day. I don't recall the exact date that he sent the trade. I'm hoping to get a response on face book from Shaun Marcum (who is actually a friend of mine... not bragging lol) as to Halladay's condition. There's no guarentee he'll know any more than what has been released.
I wouldn't take this deal if I were you.. Roberts is a stud yes, but Halladay is arguably the best pitcher in fantasy and his injury doesn't seem serious, while Hart and Saunders don't contribute too much.