ARod is D O N E !!!! Yes or No ?

[Dr Answer]

I can get Dunn/Cliff Lee/Tavares for him straight up

This clown looks completely lost and overmatched at the plate - is he done or will he come out of it !!

Opinions people.......

[angels7777]

I would hold A-Rod in this case

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=390496

[Dr Answer]

I hear ya - but I unfortunate;y watch a lot of Yankees baseball and he truly looks horrible - wondering if that hip is still bothering him

[smoovethug]

Stay put. When his .207 BABIP rises he'll be back to the 1st round talent you envision.

[briane]

He may not be the A-Rod we expect, but second round material instead of top 5 player. Keep him.

Help with mine:

viewtopic.php?t=390537

[Wiland]

Take that trade and RUN.... A-rod in his best years can't match all the stats those 3 players can help with.....

Do the math not the names.

[angels7777]

when you add 2-3 players stats just to match 1 player, of course more players produce higher numbers

[TheNephilim]

when you add 2-3 players stats just to match 1 player, of course more players produce higher numbers

I agree, who would Dunn and tavares replace. Those are pretty mediocre one sided options to plug into a starting lineup. ARod is not done, its guys like the original poster who i love to trade with, so shortsighted. Keep a rod

[sixer03fan]

I would not do this deal. That's not fair for you valuewise and why would you trade A-rod at his lowest value. He'll come around don't worry.

help?
viewtopic.php?t=390572

[Carnac]

Stand pat or regret your haste.

Comparing any one player's stats to three is comical.