Matt Holliday for BJ Upton.. Who do you like??

[cassplaya4]

I am in need of SB's and I have been offered BJ Upton for Matt Holliday

Should I make this trade?


Brian McCann (Atl - C)
Adrian Gonzalez (SD - 1B)
Aaron Hill (Tor - 2B)
Evan Longoria (TB - 3B)
Derek Jeter (NYY - SS)
Alfonso Soriano (ChC - OF)
Carlos Lee (Hou - OF)
Matt Holliday (Oak - OF)
Nate McLouth (Atl - OF) UTIL
Todd Helton (Col - 1B) BENCH
Josh Hamilton (Tex - OF) DL

Zack Greinke (KC - SP)
Jon Lester (BOS - SP)
Ted Lilly (ChC - SP)
Chris Carpenter (StL - SP)
Kevin Slowey (Min - SP)
Tommy Hanson (Atl - SP)
Francisco Cordero (Cin - RP)
Heath Bell (SD - RP)
Kerry Wood (Cle - RP)
Ryan Madson (Phi - RP)
José Valverde (Hou - RP) DL

[cassplaya4]

Now someone has an opinion, let me know fellas.

[Grover71]

I would make the deal. You have good power and average and I think BJ Upton will have a good 2nd half.

[Bakeshow]

BJ Upton is starting to show a lot of signs of being a top player and Holliday is wasting away in that ball park. You only have to worry if Holliday gets traded to a better hitting park. I'd make the trade.

Help?
viewtopic.php?t=390526

[JonLesterFanClub]

Make that trade. I think BJ will come around and have a nice second half with a ton of steals.

[cassplaya4]

Thanks guys. I am leaning towards accepting, anyone else here have a thought?

[cassplaya4]

Upton just homered and is 3-5 tonight..

[angels7777]

if you need steals you should have already made the deal

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=390496

[briane]

I'd prefer Upton.

viewtopic.php?t=390537

[sixer03fan]

[quote="Bakeshow"]BJ Upton is starting to show a lot of signs of being a top player and Holliday is wasting away in that ball park. You only have to worry if Holliday gets traded to a better hitting park. I'd make the trade.[/quote]

Couldn't agree more. Pull the trigger here I just don't think Holliday is anything special in that lineup/ballpark... and his value will only increase if he's dealt to the yankees or someone like that, which is all just speculation at this point.

help?
viewtopic.php?t=390572