C. Pena for Mike Young and D. Haren??

[edawg012]

Whats up guys so Im in a 10 team roto league 5x5, and I am in 3rd place. I have been offered Dan Haren and Mike Young for my Carlos Pena. On paper I want to do the trade, but I am giving up a lot of power and my pitching is pretty solid. Here is my roster. Thanks in advance and WHIR!

c-posada
1b-pena
2b-roberts
3b-wright
ss-barmes
if-konerko
of-beltran,n. cruz, bourn
util-rios
dl-a. cabrera, j. votto

sp-weaver,gallardo,cueto,lincecum,dice-k,price,kazmir,kuroda
rp-madson,rivera,lindstrom

[Tom Emanski AllStars]

i don't see to many power hitters on your team, and you say your pitching is good. I think you have to sit tight. On paper the deal is good, but not good for your team (if you think you could trade off haren for someone other CI than i might think about it)

[paulmarizona]

Uh, heck yes you make this trade!! I know Barmes is hot right now but you put Young at SS and Konerko at 1b.......and add Haren to your staff?? wow, Haren is one of the best pitchers right now. If the Dbacks could start scoring some runs, watch out........

i'd make that trade in a heartbeat.........

[edawg012]

BUMP

[I Stumped the Schwab]

i don't see to many power hitters on your team, and you say your pitching is good. I think you have to sit tight. On paper the deal is good, but not good for your team (if you think you could trade off haren for someone other CI than i might think about it)

i agree. Normally id make the deal in an instant, but it really wouldnt help this team much.

[briane]

While I think it may not on its own help this team, it may be the type of trade that falls into your lap, so you have to make it, and sort it out later. That's my opinion.

Help with mine:

viewtopic.php?t=390537

[Dr Answer]

make the deal and overpay a SP/low level bat for a top HR guy - maybe buy low on Dunn