Trade offer on the table - would you do this?

[steveyz]

My
Sabathia SP
for his
Justin Upton OF
K Rod RP
Tim Wakefield SP

I am seriously considering it, but would like some feedback.

Thanks and my roster is listed below
+++++++++++++++++++

ESPN H2H league

my team:

C - v. Martinez
1b - Loney
2b - Utley
3b - Chipper jones
SS - Jeter
1b/3b - Longoria
2b/SS - tejeda
util - Teahen
of - Dye
of - Cruz
of - Lind
of - Braun
of - Ordonez
bn - Manny

CC Sabathia
y. Santana
Y gallardo
harang
Price
Hanson
Nolasco
Kuroda
Smoltz
Cl- valverde
DL - Kazmir

[WyldStallyn]

i see no reason to do that. youre giving up the best player in the deal and not exactly getting great players in return.

think about who you would have to drop if you made this deal. doesnt make your return look very good, does it?

[zippytrash]

please no
you're giving up a stud for an upgrade at closer, but two steps backwards because you'll have to make room for them. I would politely decline.

[cranfire87]

I would stay away from this. Throwing in Wakefield may make the deal look better, but pretty much every SP you have is better than him. Getting Krod would force Valverde to your bench, and although Upton would be a nice upgrade over Teahan at UTIL you would still have to drop 2 more players

please help
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=390344

[steveyz]

The other manager countered with this offer after i rejected the previous trade offer

My
Sabathia SP
Teahen 3B, OF
for his
Carlos Beltran OF
Cordero RP
Verlander SP


Any comments on this offer...he really wants Sabathia.

Thanks,

[Some Guy 15]