1 for 1 AL Keeper League Trade WHIR

[mrd3licious]

Hi Everyone,
would like to know everyone's opinions on this deal.
My Aaron Hill for His Dice-K.
This was proposed to me either but i am hesitant to do it with dick-k's struggles.....
Currently, this is the first year of Hill's starting contract for our league and dice-k has this year left plus an extension for a couple years...
let me know what you think
Thanks

[RDD15]

The only way I would be taking on Matsuzaka would be if I were confident that I could flip him for a better player than Aaron Hill before the trade deadline.

[mrd3licious]

bump

[BUCCOFAN]

I dont like this deal for you, 2B is a thin position, and I think you can do better...... I just think the league has caught onto Dice-K some what.

PLEASE HELP ME:
http://www.fantasybaseballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=390157

[briane]

Would not trade Aaron Hill for Dice-K right now in a non-keeper league, and it looks like Hill has the better contract.

viewtopic.php?t=390256

[Mr. White Sock]

Definately hold on to Hill. He is still very young and he plays at a very high level. I think Dice K has been over rated ever since he came over here and won't be much of a pitcher during his career.

Help?
viewtopic.php?t=390246

[bigoz89]

I would hold onto Hill as well. I don't have any confidence in Dice K coupled with the fact that you would have Hill in his first year of contract.

A little help please: viewtopic.php?t=390122

[ab]

I really don't like Dice-k beyond this year. I'm not sure Aaron Hill is really this good, but I'm also not sure Dice-k can't get even worse.

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=390260