Hudson/Gallardo for Roberts or Phillips?

[BALCO All-Stars]

14 team, 5x5 roto, 5 keepers. I'm currently in 11th so I'm looking towards improving my keepers by getting a solid 2B, SS, or 3B. If the season ended today, I'd keep Howard/BJ Upton/C Lee/Bills/either Wieters or Gallardo. I can get Roberts for Hudson & Gallardo and I bet I can get Phillips for the same package.

In a no restrictions keeper league, who would you rather have...Roberts or Phillips? I like getting SB out of my 2B and SS spots, so I'd lean towards Roberts, but since I have BJ Upton, I can afford more power out of those spots, and that would lean me towards Phillips who is a 20/20 candidate (and 2 yrs removed from 30/30) and is younger then Roberts, but is trending towards scoring less R and has a lower AVG then Roberts...thoughts?

Current Team:

C: Posada
1B: Howard
2B: Hudson
3B: Lowell
SS: Drew
OF: BJ
OF: C Lee
OF: Vlad
UTIL: Drew
BN: Wieters, Gamel, Willy Aybar
DL: Kaz
SP: Bills/Gallardo/Oswalt/Shields/Kuroda/Doug Davis
RP: Jenks/CJ Wilson/Villaneuva/Ryan
DL: Kazmir

[BALCO All-Stars]

bump

[RowdyRed]

I'd rather have Phillips in a keeper. He's got more long term upside, IMO.

[BALCO All-Stars]

bump

[BALCO All-Stars]

Shameless bump

[taw856]

I'll go Phillips as well.