Who wins in this deal?

[Morrison8312]

I get: Pujols, Posada

I give: Adrian Gonzalez, Kinsler, Salty

12 Team, H2H

C Posada
1B Pujols
2B I. Stewart
3B C. Davis ( )
SS Rollins
CI Butler
MI Beckham
OF Rios
OF Ethier
OF Bruce
OF Scott
Util Rasmus
BN C. Gonzalez
BN J. Fields
BN Sheffield
DL Quentin

SP Gallardo
SP J. Johnson
SP C. Carpenter
SP R. Porcello
RP Franklin
P Pavano
P Arroyo

Clearly it's a work in progress but and I now need to find another Middle INF/Corner INF but I needed to shake things up. Kinsler had a terrible May, Gonzalez will probably slow down a little bit. Thoughts?

[Rhinochasers]

I would stick with what you have. AGonz will not drop that much and Kinsler is still a top 10, he will bounce back.

[RDD15]

I would not do the deal.