should I trade Morneau for Billingsly & Rodney?

[GFunkEra21]

5 x5 roto 12-team non-keeper

My roster-
C-R.Martion
C-M.Olivio
1b-Morneau
2b-DeRosa
SS-Hanley
MI-Fontetot
CI-Giambi
3b-Lowell
OF-Ibanez
OF-Dye
OF-Melky Caberara
OF-McCutcheon
OF-Rowand
DH-Hafner

SP-Lester
SP-Lowe
SP-Baker
SP-Marquis
SP-Danks
SP-Wang
SP-S.West
P-Papelbon
P-K Rod

Bench
Manny
Bartlett
Franceour
M.Bradley
Kazmir
Lohse

Currently I'm

AVG- 1st
HR's= 3rd (6 behind leader)
RBI= 1st by 20
Runs=2nd
SB's=11th
ERA=12th
WHIP=12th
K's=12th
Wins-7th (6 wins behind leader)
Saves-3rd- (3 behind leader)

He also has Cordero, Qualls and Downs..was thinking of countering for Cordero..

Any Help/???? thanks

[GFunkEra21]

bump

[pangbones]

No. I wouldn't do it. I'd drop Wang he's the reason you're so bad in ERA, whip. Cut him and find someone else to plug in.

Heres mine
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=390021

[Seanyfever]

Ditto. I'd pass. I like Bills.... Rodney adds no value for me. Have him buck up on the second player.

Return the favour
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=390027

[GFunkEra21]

I'm up in the air on this offer. Then consider this:

Around mid-July Morneau typically starts to tank.

Pre-All Star: 1564 AB, .302 BA, 93 HRs, 327 RBIs
Post-All Star: 1352 AB, .267 BA, 56 HRs, 250 RBIs

any more help??? thanks

[RowdyRed]

You say you want to do it, then do it. But Morneau is worth more than that. Rodney does nothing for me, and Billingsley is behind Morneau, even if you take into account second half struggles on the career. A lot of that is in last year's struggles after the ASB, I think. He really struggled after the ASB last year.