Trade Valverde or Street for Bruce or Chris Davis?

[JaysFan]

So, this guy, lets just call him "my brother" LOL, wants a closer. I want power and have Valverde coming of the DL. He has already offered me Chris Davis for Huston Street. He also mentioned he may be willing to part with Bruce. Would you do any of the following trades GIVEN my roster?

a) I give Street I get Chris Davis
b) I give Street I get Jay Bruce
c) I give Valverde I get Jay Bruce

9 TEAM 6x6 mixed redraft league - HR, AVG, RBI, RUNS, OPS and W, K, ERA, WHIP, SV, QS

C- Martin 1B- Loney 2B- Phillips SS- Hanley 3B- Longoria CI- Overbay MI- Uggla
OF- Pence,Hunter,Rios,Alexei Ramirez, Reimold
UTIL- J. Rivera, Winn BENCH- ManRam, C Young, Burrell
DL- Votto
SP- Halladay, Cueto RP- Broxton, Bell P- Street, Marmol, Garza, Jurjens
BENCH- Jimenez, Happ DL- Valverde

[woodson_28]

If it's me, I would go w/ trade B: Giving up Street for Bruce.

I'm not very big on C. Davis since there are talks of Smoak coming up, which could result in a Davis demotion, or loss of playing time. I also like Valverde better than Street, as Valverde will have twice as many K's as Street

help me? viewtopic.php?t=389989

[JaysFan]

Would you do b over doing NOTHING AT ALL?