scherzer,baker,kershaw,smoltz WHIR

[fierro33]

out of these 4 who would u rather own and how would u rank them


scherzer
baker
kershaw
smoltz


10 team 5x5 h2h non keeper

C Mauer
1b Miggy
2b Roberts
3b Arod
ss Rollins
OF Crawford
OF Mclouth
OF Ichiro
Util Adam Jones
Manny
aaron hill
Ethier

Sabathia
Gallardo
Josh Johnson
Wainwright
Slowey
Baker

Lidge DL
Capps
Fuentes
Ryan Madsen

[Members Only Jackets]

Non keeper:
1. smoltz - chip on shoulder. good offense=wins.
2. scherzer - less inconsistant than kershaw w/ big upside , lots of ks
3. kershaw - big, big upside but still learning and developing.
4. baker - good but i'd rather have the upside guys over him


viewtopic.php?t=389982

[woodson_28]

I'd switch 1 and 2:

1. Scherzer
2. Smoltz
3. Kershaw
4. Baker

Scherzer has looked very solid this year, plus he has a huge k/9 ratio. Smoltz is the best SP, but you have to be a little concerned w/ his age + injury.

help me? viewtopic.php?t=389989

[fierro33]

scherzer was snatched up......
between baker,kershaw, and smoltz who should i get

[yearbend]

why not all 3? who do you have on your pitching staff or bench? im sure these pitchers can replace some of your current ones.

but if only one id take kershaw.

[angels7777]

for me: Baker, Smoltz, Kershaw

viewtopic.php?t=390077