Miguel Cabrera Trade.....

[DaShiz23]

12 Team 5x5 Roto 6 Player Keeper (1st Place; low in SB and Saves)
His Miguel Cabrera
for
My Justin Upton and Jermaine Dye

Value-wise, I like it. Keeper-wise, it creates a logjam. Thoughts?

C Posada
1B Adrian Gonzalez
2B Brian Roberts
3B Adrian Beltre
SS Jimmy Rollins
OF Ryan Braun
OF Justin Upton
OF Jermaine Dye
UTIL Adam Dunn
BN Adam Jones
BN Chris Davis
DL Josh Hamilton

SP Greinke
SP Cliff Lee
RP Kevin Gregg
RP Scott Downs
P Mike Gonzalez
P JP Howell
P Roy Oswalt
BN Derek Lowe
BN Ryan Dempster
BN Max Scherzer

[hett2333]

Value wise it's good, but if your in first place and if your going to make a trade why aren't you addressing your needs? You said your low in SB and saves, so if your going to make a deal don't you want to improve in those two categories? This trade doesn't address either...

viewtopic.php?t=389934

[WyldStallyn]

in a keeper theres no way you can turn down getting mcab

[bosoxrock34]

Mcab will only get better and better as he gets older he should develop more power.... As long as he doesnt get too fat lol..

some help
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=389940

[DaShiz23]

in a keeper theres no way you can turn down getting mcab

This was my thought exactly. Anyone else?

[angels7777]

ya I think in a keeper you have to do it - probably the only reason he even offered this trade is due to M-Cab's nagging hamstring issues

[DaShiz23]

I made the deal. Having Miggy, Braun, Hamilton,Rollins ( ), Adrian Gonzalez, and Greinke as a start for a keeper ain't bad.
I know it's early, but would these be your six? I would have to throw back Roberts and Adam Jones. Too early to think of this?

[Geek]

Roberts and Jones are both better than Rollins.

[Chicago RedSox]

Roberts and Jones are both better than Rollins.

I was going to say the same thing. Jones is fantastic, and I believe his SB will pick up too.

[angels7777]

it's too early to tell I think - check Rollins numbers at the end of the year and see if Jones can continue to produce over the course of an entire season - Hamilton is a guy you should probably keep but he is a guy I try to avoid every year due his injuries and prior drug use (I think his body will break down quicker because of this)