help! WHIR 100%

[sigriffey]

Markakis
Bay
Holliday
Upton

[jakesnake48]

Markakis
Bay
Upton
Holliday

[Seanyfever]

Seems this is allover a bit..

I do like Markakis as the upper man here...

I liek Upton the least... I actually related with the earlier Rocco comment. Good comparison.

Bay and Holliday is something of a debate. Most seem to be giving Holliday the thumbs down. Saying several things about Coors effect. I like him, and some forget that Bay struggled a tad in Pittsburgh. He can be benefiting from Boston lineup. Two years ago, all would have flipped Bay for Holliday. I like Holliday to come about and even more with friendly environment- even not Coors.

Markakis
Holliday
Bay

Upton

Return the favour
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=390027

[michaelyoung4prez]

1. Markakis
2. Bay
3. Upton
4. Holliday

[briane]

1. Markakis - young and already proven
2. Upton - young and most talented of the bunch (rank #2 in a long term keeper where you can choose each year, not one where you get locked in)
3. Bay - 30 years old, in a great lineup and a great park if he stays
4. Holliday - 29 years old, who knows where he lands

Though the difference between #3 and #4 is completely based on lineup and park issues.

viewtopic.php?t=390256

[ab]

Markakis
Upton
Bay
Holliday

You can switch Upton and Bay and I wouldn't argue with you

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=390260