C Russell Martin (LAD - C) 1B Justin Morneau (Min, 1B) 2B Chone Figgins (LAA, 2B, 3B) 3B Miguel Cabrera (Det 1B, 3B) SS J.J. Hardy (Mil, SS) OF Alfonso Soriano (Chc, OF) OF Adam Lind (Tor, OF) OF Johnny Damon (NYY, OF) UT Aaron Hill (Tor, 2B) UT Vladimir Guerrero (LAA, OF) DL Jason Bartlett (TB, SS)
SP Jered Weaver (LAA, SP) SP Felix Hernandez (Sea, SP) SP Chad Billingsley (LAD, SP) RP Mariano Rivera (NYY, RP) RP Brian Fuentes (LA, RP) P David Aardsma (Sea, RP) P Frank Francisco (Tex, RP) P Rasndy Wolf (Lad, SP) BN Francisco Liriano (Min, SP) BN Matt Garza (TB, SP) BN Ted Lilly (Chc, SP) BN Carlos Zambrano (ChC, SP)
His team is;
Kurt Suzuki (Oak - C) Russell Branyan (Sea - 1B,3B) Chase Utley (Phi - 2B) David Wright (NYM - 3B) Derek Jeter (NYY - SS) Vernon Wells (Tor - OF) Matt Holliday (Oak - OF) Adam Jones (Bal - OF) Yunel Escobar (Atl - SS) Ryan Ludwick (StL - OF) Shane Victorino (Phi - OF)
Kevin Millwood (Tex - SP) John Lackey (LAA - SP) Joe Nathan (Min - RP) Bobby Jenks (CWS - RP) Trevor Hoffman (Mil - RP) Adam Wainwright StL - SP) Kevin Gregg (ChC - RP) CC Sabathia (NYY - SP) John Danks (CWS - SP) Jon Lester (Bos - SP) Bobby Parnell (NYM - RP)
To answer your question, it depends on what his other needs are, and if needs a SP, and also how high he is on Hardy. If he needs a SP, maybe offer Garza or Zambrano, or one of your starters, and plug in Garza or Zambrano into your rotation. Also, I am a fan of Bartlett, and with him starting his rehab assignment, you may be able to wait on Bartlett. I don't like either trade A or B, i think Damon is a better player than Wells, esp. with the lineup around him who can knock him in. If i were you, i would wait until Bartlett comes back and see what he can do.
Personally I like either of those deals, but then I'm not sold on Damon keeping it up all year. Damon was a guy most people had as an OF3 at best and a borderline bench player at worst at the start of the year, and while he's proven himself early on this season, I wouldn't call it unreasonable to even predict Wells outproducing him the rest of the way. It's not that I don't like Damon, and it's not that I'm saying he absolutely won't be better than Wells, because he certainly could be, but I just think it's way more of a lock that Jeter is an upgrade over Bartlett than Damon over Wells.
I'm not crazy about Damon either, and would take the first deal. I own Jeter in one of my leagues and have been very happy with his production so far. Bartlett is still a sell high-ish candidate to me personally.
It's not ideal to have that many people from the same team, but it's no reason to turn down a deal that works for you. After all, there's nothing preventing you from then making another equal value swap later on if it's just about getting some diversity in your lineup.