Porcello and Murphy for Meche/Crisp?(WHIR)

[kidsilk]

Now the guy said he would do the deal for Romero or Richmond as well. Both of them are on 3 year contracts whereas Meche is on a 1 year deal. Would one of them be worth it instead?

[kiddlattimer]

Crisp is pretty underrated id rather have that side.

[moose32]

i like the meche side

[angels7777]

I like the Meche/Crisp side as well...

[Sportsmonkey]

I'd hang Porcello in a keeper league. I don't think the upside of Crisp is worth anything. Porcello is the real deal and will increase his K rate as he gets better.

[dagactor]

Meche/Crisp is the better side.

[Gang Green]

I like your counter. Interestingly enough, I'd say that Meche and Porcello have a similar value for this season. Since you'd be getting an upgrade in the OF, it's certainly worth it.

Thanks for the help on mine.

I think Meche and Porcello are a wash as far as keepers. Meche will be better the rest of this year and Porcello in another 2 years will be the better pitcher. If you can upgrade Crisp from Murphy, go for it.

[pangbones]

I see Porcello fading as the season goes on. He may even end up in the bullpen at some point, because they'll want to limit his innings and depending on D Train and Bonderman they may not need him in there. I'd definitely make that trade. You get a big upgrade with Crisp, and I like Meche to outproduce Porcello.