Porcello and Murphy for Meche/Crisp?(WHIR)

[kidsilk]

AL only league, 10 teams, 23 man rosters, 7 keepers with 3 year contracts, 5x5 roto

A guy offered me Coco Crisp and Brad Bergensen for RIck Porcello and David Murphy and I turned that down. If I countered with Gil Meche and Crisp for Porcello and Murphy would that be worth it? I already tried Porcello and Murphy for Crisp and Burnett but he turned that one down. Here are our rosters: I like Crisp's potential and speed so if you dont like this for me can you see any other options? Thanks and leave your links.

My Team:

C-Wieters
C-Zaun
1B-MCab
2B-J.Lopez
SS-M. Izturis
3B-ARod
MI-Getz
CI-Konerko
OF-Wells
OF-Hunter
OF-Murphy
OF-Morales
OF-Kubel
DH-Thome

P-J. Shields
P-Porcello
P-Sonnanstine
P-Morrow
P-Francisco
P-Downs
P-Cahill
P-Pettitte
P-Bonderman

DL-McCarthy
DL-S. Lewis
DL-Johjima

Minors-Poreda
Minors-LaPorta

His Team:

C-Inge
C-Navarro
1B-Teix
2B-Kendrick
SS-E. Aybar
3B-Scutaro
MI-Crosby
CI_Millar
OF-B. Anderson
OF-Crisp
OF-Griffey
OF-Scott
OF-Swisher
DH-Larish

P-Burnett
P-Buerhle
P-Bedard
P-Meche
P_Bergensen
P-Casilla
P-Richard
P-Richmond
P-Ryan

DL-Guillen
DL-Hamilton
DL-Harrison
DL-Percival

Minors-Lillibridge

[kidsilk]

can anyone help me out here?

[kidsilk]

bump

[Andy1234]

I think Meche/Crisp would be a good return for Porcello/Murphy

Help with mine:Which 2B? Lopez, DeRosa, or Kendrick

[PinstripePride]

I think Meche/Crisp would be a good return for Porcello/Murphy

Help with mine:Which 2B? Lopez, DeRosa, or Kendrick

i agree but i rather have Crisp n Porcello lol so try n work that one out

viewtopic.php?t=389715

[kidsilk]

Can anyone help me out from the Thursday morning crowd?

[Willy T 4 MVP]

as i've said in a few other posts, i really think porcello's production has been a mirage thus far. he's supremely talented, but he's a low K guy who's still very inexperienced. for a pitcher like that to contribute in fantasy it usually takes 3-4 years of maturation. it's diff with a young talented K pitcher, b/c they dont have to have pinpoint control/command to be effective.


i would take the meche side for sure.



help w mine? viewtopic.php?f=26&t=389742

[sleepyadam702]

I would take the meche side. I think meche is underrated. He has high K potential and does not give up the long ball.

[TheBambino]

Thanks for my help

I too like the meche and Crisp side... meche is really starting to form!

[plapre3]

I like your counter. Interestingly enough, I'd say that Meche and Porcello have a similar value for this season. Since you'd be getting an upgrade in the OF, it's certainly worth it.

Thanks for the help on mine.