My ARod, Braun, Phillips and Joba for HIS Johan, Kinsler, Pence and Lowel
I don't like this trade, but he does have some good pitching that I would like to have. Here is his team... HIS TEAM: C - Martin 1B - Helton 2B Kinsler 3B Lowell SS Escobar OF Pence OF Crawford OF Lind UTIL Figgins BN Quentin
I'm not sure if I want to give up all those big names. I'd be OK with trading ARod or Braun, but think I would need more from him than just that. I guess I could do ARod, Phillips, and Joba for Santana, Kinsler and someone else? I don't know. Help please? Do I just stay as is?
I know my team is stacked so don't ask if it's real or not. A couple trades and pickups with a good draft gave me this.
WHIR!
MY TEAM: C - Matt Wieters 1b - Albert Pujols 2b - Brandon Phillips 3b - Alex Rodriguez SS - Michael Young OF - Johnny Damon OF - Ryan Braun OF - Jacoby Ellsbury Util - Miguel Cabrera Bn - Vlad Guerero
SP - Josh Beckett SP - CC Sabathia RP - Bobby Jenks RP - Jonathon Broxton P - Joakim Soria P - Andrew Bailey P - Joba Chamberlain BN Chris Young BN Chris Carpenter BN Tommy Hanson BN Max Scherzer DL - Edinson Volquez
Yahoo Keeper H2H League 2 hitters 2 pitchers. Standard scoring plus (Cycle, Grand Slam - Complete Game, No Hitter)
Yahoo H2H league- 10 teams Keeper: 2 batters, 2 pitchers
You're on the losing end (big-time) of two players, and on not enough of a winning side of the other two to make up the difference. Depends on your needs and position in the standings, I guess, but I don't take this deal unless he throws in something juicy.
You're on the losing end (big-time) of two players, and on not enough of a winning side of the other two to make up the difference. Depends on your needs and position in the standings, I guess, but I don't take this deal unless he throws in something juicy.
Not too good to look at it that way you have to compare the bset players in the deal and go down. The way I see it:
Braun as of now is the best player your giving up followed by a close Arod. I see Braun as better than Johan even more so with your SP depth. Arod is higher up than Kinsler and with phillps/joba not being too much of a diffrence from pence/Lowell but the phills side is better. In this trade your giving up too much If you really want Johan that bad a trade with maybe a package deal going for johan and buy low on quentin would work out for you.
I htink it is pretty close but I say no deal. You don't need Johan. If you had zero SP, then I'd say yes. See if you can lose the Braun/Pence part of the deal. It makes a better deal for you if you can.
You're on the losing end (big-time) of two players, and on not enough of a winning side of the other two to make up the difference. Depends on your needs and position in the standings, I guess, but I don't take this deal unless he throws in something juicy.
I hate deals like this... there's just too much going on, with too many big names involved. Scale it back a bit, and put AROD or Braun out on the block to get two second or thrid rounders back, and you'll do better for helping you team.
Cafe Home
Fantasy Football
Fantasy Basketball
Fantasy Hockey
by Therobsclub » Tue Jun 09, 2009 8:56 pm 
