Bay/Hamilton (Better Keeper) WHIR

[crod8712]

H2H, 14 TEAMS, Keep 15

Stat categories: AVG, HR, R, SB, RBI, W, ERA, WHIP, K, S

Should I deal Bay for Hamilton? I am pretty much guranteed to be in the playoffs because my team is stacked so I am looking long-term.

Lineups

Catcher: Victor Martinez C/1B
First Baseman: Mark Teixeira 1B
Second Baseman: Brandon Phillips 2B
Third Baseman: Miguel Cabrera 3B/1B
Short Stop: Hanley Ramirez SS
Out Field: Curtis Granderson OF
Out Field: Jason Bay OF
Out Field: Ichiro Suzuki OF
Utility: Brandon Inge OF/C/3B
Utilty: Derrek Lee 1B

Bench: Jeremy Hermida OF
Bench: Cameron Maybin OF
Bench: Delmon Young OF

DL: Rickie Weeks 2B

Starting Pitchers:
1. C.C. Sabathia
2. Jake Peavy
3. Cliff Lee
4. Felix Hernanadez
5. Matt Cain
6. Brett Anderson
7. Sean West

Relief Pitchers:
1. J.P. Howell
2. Matt Lindstrom
3. C.J. Wilson
4. Huston Street
5. Mike MacDougal

DL: Joey Devine

[cwhitty]

I think I like Bay just a tad more. Just seems to be the safer play. He will probably be resigning with Boston too so that should keep his value safe. Can't imagine the Sawx let him go.

Please help
viewtopic.php?t=389354

[HOOTIE]

Hamilton. A healthy Hamilton, which he should be, once he gets back.

[cococrisp]

Hamilton, easily Hamilton. He's young, on a mission and can rake there.

[wkpdpack]

Tough choice. I'd have to say Bay right now. He's been awesome this year and is young. Don't see him slowing down in the Boston lineup.

Please help with my post viewtopic.php?t=389391

[crod8712]

Still willing to help others who help me....I'm split!

[saemick]

I would wait till the end of the season, but as of this moment, you have to go with Bay. Hamilton seems to be extremely injury prone, while Bay just keeps putting on consistent #'s.

IF we're talking both healthy...than Hamilton has a much higher ceiling, but tough to count on him to be healthy

help:

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=389484

[crod8712]

I declined.

[Yahtzeee]

Hamilton is the better keeper in my opinion. It's hard telling though how he will finish this year even once this injury business is taken care of. One could argue that Bay will outperform Hamilton when he returns for this year, but next year, I'd rather have Hamilton.

[Carl Johnson]

Hamliton can rake but has missed a lot of time in his career thus far. Id go with the consistancy of bay, whos looking more and more studly everyday.



mine:
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=389671